This post is from January 2009. Facts and links may have changed since. See more from that month

Article2 min read

Target: Dimona

click on the image for a larger version

A recent London Times article reports that Israel is worried about Hamas using its artillery rockets to shell the Dimona reactor. I thought it would be interesting to calculate the probability of one of those rockets actually hitting the reactor containment vessel, which is 18 m is radius. Of course, if it was really an artillery rocket, it might have to hit it twice, once to penetrate the containment vessel and once to blow up the reactor. But that is a refinement we won’t go into right now.

Of course, we need to decide which rocket Hamas might actually use. The Times reports the Israelis are worried about the Fajr-3, which, according to globalsecurity.org, has a range of 45 km while Dimona is approximately 80 km away from the closest point to the Gaza Strip. So it’s probably not the Fajr-3. Perhaps they meant the Fajr-5, which has a range, according to globalsecurity.org, of 75 km. While Dimona is seemingly beyond the range of even the Fajr-5, there is considerable uncertainty in those sorts of quantities so it is at least possible.

If we use the 3000 m CEP for the Fajr-5, there is a 0.004% chance that its 90 kg warhead will hit the reactor containment vessel. (The only reference I found for the Fajr-5’s CEP was by Oliver Schmidt which lists it as 3000 m.) If, on the other hand, Hamas had managed to smuggle in Zalzel-2 guided missiles, which is said to have a CEP of 200 m, then there is a 0.3% chance of hitting the containment vessel with each rocket.

Geoff Forden

Writing on ACW 2008–2010

Dr. Forden has been at MIT since 2000 where his research includes the analysis of Russian and Chinese space systems as well as trying to understand how proliferators acquire the know-how and industrial infrastructure to produce weapons of mass destruction.

All posts by Geoff Forden