This post is from December 2004. Facts and links may have changed since. See more from that month

Article1 min read

Physics 101: Boost Phase Missile Defense and the Shortfall Problem

Taylor Dinerman writing with a crayon over at The Space Review says:

“In the case of boost-phase weapons, the debris will fall back on the nation that launched the missile.”

Fall back? What kind of non-ballistic trajectory is that missile on? It’s called Newton’s first law of motion. Look into it.

Whatever debris remains will fall forward including the warhead, likely killing plenty of people where it lands. In some cases, according to Geoff Forden (see chart below), murdering more people than the terrorists on September 11, 2001.

Of course, many of those people are in Turkey, Europe and Canada for a missile traveling from Iran (Russia, China and Canada for one traveling from North Korea), so perhaps they don’t count for Mr. Dinerman. For detailed discussions of the “shortfall” problem—as in the warhead falling short, not Dinerman’s high school physics education—see:

  • Geoffrey Forden, “Laser defenses: What if they work?” Bulletin of Atomic Scientists, 58:5 (September/October 2002_: 48-53.
  • Report of the APS Study Group on Boost-Phase Intercept Systems for National Missile Defense (July 15, 2003): 96-99.

Jeffrey Lewis

Writing on ACW 2004–2026

Dr. Jeffrey Lewis is a Senior Research Scholar and the William J. Perry Lecturer at Stanford University's Center for International Security and Cooperation. He is also a Distinguished Fellow at the Foreign Policy Research Institute. Jeffrey is a member of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine's Committee on International Security and Arms Control (CISAC), which conducts dialogues with counterparts in China, Russia, and India; a member of the Science and Security Board of the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, which is best known for setting the "Doomsday Clock"; and a member of Anthropic's Frontier Red Team. From 2022 to 2025, Jeffrey was a member of the U.S. Secretary of State's International Security Advisory Board.

All posts by Jeffrey Lewis